1. I'm a big fan of the flexibility and capabilities that the digital format offers. But, something just doesn't feel right about this. Maybe it's psychological, but I like to know that my CDs, DVDs, digital files, etc. are there for me on-demand, no internet connection required, as a personal audience experience.

I don't want to constantly feed 14 marketing departments up and down the music industry food chain. There's a freedom in feeling like you own something, even if it's just for your own personal use.

It makes me want to head to the local record store, pick up a few CDs and play them on my old home stereo. No earbuds, no rating my favorite tracks, creating playlists, iMixes, or writing reviews...and no forced low-quality bitrates. It's a user experience focused on the enjoyment of creative content, and nothing else.

Posted at 5:59AM on Dec 19th 2005 by TW

2. I agree w/the last comment. I would never use a service like this. I LOVE digital music - I've digitized my 500+ CD collection and can't imagine life without my Creative Zen mp3 player and the ability to bring that much music with me wherever I go. But I see plans such as this as a way to further push advertising and marketing on to people. Want to play the new CD you just bought? - sure, go to Apple I-whatever and just simply log in and play - we'll store it for you. Nevermind that you'll be bombarded with endless ads and sponsors and well-placed marketing. I'd much rather own what I've paid for and have total control over it.

Posted at 5:59AM on Dec 19th 2005 by esskay