Rumors are surfacing once again that music labels are trying to capitalize on the demand for purchased downloads by
raising the wholesale cost of music. The
latest such report is in this
morning's Financial Times (thanks to Phil Leigh for the notice). To say
that raising prices would be foolish is an understatement, but the attempt does seem characteristic of the
short-sightededness of the music industry. Myopia has caused many of the industry's current problems, and labels will
and should) continue to be punished for denying marketplace reality and mishandling opportunities.
At this stage in the evolution of a-la-carte online stores, the only priority should be building volume. As it is,
wholesale costs are high for providers such as Apple's iTMS, which must pay the labels a negotiated fee per track as
well as mechanical costs (that is, unnegotiated licenses available to any performer or store) to publishers. To think
that the success of iTMS is an indicator of consumer acceptance of higher prices is unfathomable arrogance, but even if
online sales remained strong at higher prices the entire industry needs much, much more volume before a-la-carte
downloading really lifts off.












